Originally Posted by wellrestedunfullfilled
Which dildo has the most realistic feel ? I have never heard that brought up...
You've never heard it brought up because hardly anyone who wants a dildo considers "realistic" to be a particularly desirable trait.
There are so many real penises around willing to fuck anything that will hold still, that a silicone direct substitute is kind of pointless, unless you want to imagine it belongs to a specific guy who is unobtainable or who you're in a long-distance relationship with.
Generally the goals in dildo selection are maximum pleasure (often better provided by a shape wildly different from a real penis, not to mention the addition of a vibrator) and easy clean-up/easy battery replacement/quietness of motor.
But, if you actually wanted a dildo that felt super-realistic, what you'd want is the kind that can be inflated with warm water.