Story Discussion: 08/06/07 'A Special Christmas Present' by Rumple Foreskin

Rumple Foreskin

The AH Patriarch
Joined
Jan 18, 2002
Posts
11,109
The original version of this romance story was a one-page entry in the 2004 "Winter Holiday" writing contest here at Lit. What now faces you is an expanded (5300 word) version I'm hoping the folks at Phaze will relax their standards enough to use in the upcoming FROST anthology (deadline 09/01/07).

My chief worry with this first-person yarn is related to several current threads here at the SDC; is there too much narrative in the opening? If so, can the problem be remedied w/o rewriting the entire story?

Your sage wisdom, counsel, and advice on that issue and/or any other aspect of the story will be appreciated.

Rumple Foreskin :cool:

==

A Special Christmas Present
by Rumple Foreskin

My mother is always right, trust me. Not sometimes or most of the time, but always. Take last week, for instance. Thanks to her, I was, about halfway between Macy’s and totally broke, sitting alone in the mall’s noisy food-court while she finished shopping and getting her nails done, eating a tasteless salad, and wondering how I let her con me into getting dressed and driving into town to shop with her the day after Thanksgiving, the busiest shopping day of the year.

She was right, of course. Like I said, my mother is always right. To prove the point, I’d somehow managed to finish off my Christmas list. That’s good, since I’m going to be a little busy about then.

That shop-a-thon cost me more than just max’ed out credit cards. My back ached, my feet throbbed, and the rest of me felt tired, bloated and crappy. To be fair, all that started long before I hit the mall. Being eight months pregnant can do that to a girl.

Make that an unmarried, pregnant girl. Of course, I’m no girl either, although it does seem like I stopped growing a lot sooner than the owner’s manual told my parent’s to expect. In her infinite wisdom, Mother Nature decided five-foot nothing was more than enough for Becky Miller to handle. So there’s not a whole lot of me to pack around a baby that keeps getting bigger by the hour and seems anxious to climb out and look around.

It’s not like I didn’t know better. This baby will be my second. My first, Kylie, is two going on twenty-five and can’t wait to play with her baby brother. But knowing better and doing what’s smart isn’t the same thing. At least it isn’t for me, not after falling in love with someone I may never see again.

The baby’s daddy left the country not knowing I was pregnant or in love with him. And I wasn’t, in love that is, not at first.

We’d known each other forever. But then everybody knows everybody else out where we live. In high school, we fooled around a little, you know, making out in the back seat of cars, sneaking out of parties for a smoke, things like that. And once, at a college party, we both got wasted and did more than just make out.

But we never dated, even after that. Don’t ask me why. Maybe both of us wanted the other to make the first move. Anyway, at the end of that semester I sort of quit, sort of flunked out of school and married Stuart Litton.

A week before the wedding, Matt warned me about him. I said he sounded just like my mother, who claimed being a self-centered jerk was Stuart’s best feature. Like an idiot, I ignored them. Later that summer, Matt joined the service.

Both he and my mother were right about Stuart. Being married was a lot of fun, at first. But the fun and games became fewer and fewer as things went from bad, to worse, to dangerous. About this time last year, I came limping home with Kylie and a black eye. My self-centered jerk of a husband, gave me both.

To her credit, my mother hugged us, cried while I told my story, and never said, “I told you so.” What she did say was bad enough. Matt had been wounded while doing whatever it was he did. According to her, he really had come limping home a few days before with his left leg in a cast.

The next day, I drove over to his parent’s house with Kylie. After her usual two minutes of shyness, she was all over him. When I tried to stop her, he indicated it was all right. While tickling her belly, he gave me a quick glance, gestured at my eye, and mouthed, “Stuart?” I nodded. He grimaced, shook his head, and went back to tickling Kylie.

While they played, I studied Matt. Back in high school, he’d been a good-looking, all-everything jock with a boyish smile and teasing attitude that was just a little cocky. A lot of girls had serious crushes on him. The Matt I now saw, while still blonde and good-looking, was no boy.

The skin under his stubble wasn’t tan so much as a hard, weathered brown. There were tiny creases around the corners of his eyes. And once I noticed those familiar blue-eyes get this funny, distant look. Most of all, the cockiness was gone, replaced by an easy self-confidence.

In other words, he was a man—and I wanted him. It’d been a long time since I’d experienced that delicious flutter I now felt in my stomach. Way too long.

The next day, I called to tell him I was coming by with a special Christmas present just for him. It was a weekday. His parents would be at work. That meant we’d be alone and, if I had my way, soon making love.

I walked in through the back door, the way everyone in the country does. He was sitting on a stool in the kitchen next to an empty coffee cup, looking at the paper. He’d shaved, and it made him look more like the Matt I remembered. I’d worn my tightest jeans, but the old high school t-shirt he had on looked even tighter. If it hadn’t been for that damn cast I might have jumped him right then. As it was, he gave me this sexy grin that almost buckled my knees and asked in a teasing voice, “Hello, Becky. Now, what’d you bring me?”

“It’s a surprise. I hope you’ll like it,” I said, trying to remain calm while hurrying out of my new leather car coat and tossing it toward the nearest chair. I missed and decided it could stay on the floor.

“Sounds great,” he said. “So what’s my present?”

I stepped past the cast, put my arms around his neck and, in a voice I hoped sounded sexy, said, “Me. I’m your present.”

Just thinking about the kiss that followed can still turn me on. Matt’s upper body was bigger, harder, more muscular than I remembered. It explained why that old high school t-shirt was so tight. But his lips were soft and his tongue was so incredibly smooth and sexy.

If we never stopped kissing it would have been too soon for me, except if we didn’t get down to some serious loving in a big hurry, I was going to start making like Blanche Dubois and rip that damn t-shirt off him.

Matt’s lips brushed against mine and I heard him say, “Let’s go to the living room.”

My eyes popped open in surprise. “Not your bedroom?”

“Single bed,” he said, giving his cast an explanatory thump. We headed for the living room.

I remember grabbing a big afghan off the couch and spreading it out on the carpet. The next thing I recall was Matt interrupting a very thorough job of licking and sucking my nipples to look up at me. "Becky Miller, you do have the most delectable boobs.”

By then my sweater and bra were off and I was sure my jeans and panties were about to follow them. A few small logs burned in the nearby fireplace. The lights on the big Christmas tree were turned on. Just like me.

I stroked his short, blonde hair and grinned. "Don’t give me that, crap. We both know I'm an original member of the Itty Bitty Titty Club.”

"Size don't mean jack-shit. I’ve always told you that." Matt circled a nipple with the tip of his tongue and I shivered with pleasure. "Quality means a lot more that quantity. Believe me, yours are first-rate. In fact, while these prime samples of female flesh may not be the biggest, they are, without doubt, still the finest pair I've ever had the pleasure of enjoying."

I don’t mind having small breasts. In fact, I prefer mine to the big udders most guys seem to go nuts over. That’s just as well. Even after having Kylie, there was little change in mine. At most, they went from hard-fried eggs to sunny-side up. Matt’s gentle teasing and compliments reminded me how sweet he could be, and how much I wanted him.

"If that’s what you think, then there’s more than just your leg that needs attention. Lay back and let me deliver the rest of your Christmas present."

Matt grinned, and reached for my jeans. “Well, if you insist. But you’re way too overdressed for gift giving.”

That problem was soon corrected. Wearing nothing but an eager smile, I knelt beside him and pulled off that damn tight shirt. After that, I helped him roll over onto his back.

We paused to touch and look at one another. To my surprise I didn’t feel self-conscious, perhaps because I was too fascinated by his body. There was a scar I’d never seen before on his shoulder. When I asked about it, he shrugged and said he fell.

I leaned over and kissed him. It was another good one, but nowhere near enough. I covered his face with kisses and nibbled on his ears and neck. After giving that scar a long kiss, I worked my way down his hard torso, taking my time and sampling various parts along the way. When my lips reached the waistband of his sweats, I found myself starring past it at a very big bulge and feeling this incredible sexual rush.

With that cast in the way, getting those sweats off became a two-person operation. Even with his help, it wasn’t easy. The first couple of times I tried to tug them down, they caught on that bulge. Not until I untied the drawstring and lifted the waistband was I able to expose the problem, so to speak.

His cock was long and thick and bobbing in anticipation. I bent over and ran my tongue up the hard shaft, then slipped my lips around the smooth head and took my time sucking it into my mouth. After a few slow trips up and down the shaft, I picked up speed while taking all I could and, for a change, loving every last inch.

I’d zoned out by then, so it took a second to tune in on his voice. I could tell he was struggling to keep it calm. “This is, uh, in-fucking-credible. The thing is, unless you want a messy snack, you better back off. Climb on top and we’ll finish together."

It was a sweet, even considerate, suggestion. But this was fun. I removed the glistening cock from my mouth and licked the smooth head like an ice cream cone. Then I cut my eyes up at him and winked. “Thanks, but I really don't mind the taste, well, not too much. So, I think I'll finish what I've started. Besides, I've never done it that way, you know, on top."

"Are you shitting me?”

"I shit you not," I said, between long licks.

"But all those guys you dated, and that jerk you married?” Matt and I had always been confidants. There were few secrets between us. He knew I never cheated on any of my boyfriends but the rest of the time, well, that was different.

"The back seat of a car kinda limits your possibilities. And Stuart’s the macho type who always wants to be in charge."

"Damn. I warned you he was a running dumb-ass. Come on up here, lady, and let me teach you a thing or two."

With Matt's encouragement and help, I managed to straddle his middle, only to jump right off and wrap the cast in his sweats. That thing could hurt.

Once back on top and in position, I slowly lowered my bottom, savoring the feel of his cock burrowing into me. The further I sank, the deeper it penetrated. When the last few inches slid into place, I let out a sigh of total pleasure. Damn, but that felt so good.

We stayed still at first, sharing the sensation, then Matt began rocking his hips as much as the cast would allow, driving even deeper inside me. I responded to the pressure by leaning forward, putting my hands on his shoulders, and pressing my hips down to meet his upward thrusts.

Either Matt’s a great teacher, or I’m a quick learner. Maybe both. I was soon setting the pace, pumping up and down his long, hard shaft and loving every minute of this new experience.

My body raced toward a much needed orgasm. When it struck, I jerked upright, then gasped at the sudden pressure inside my pussy and tried to lean forward. Matt caught me and pushed me back. He cupped my breasts, squeezing them and twisting the nipples while forcing me to stay erect.

Maybe it was the position, but one climax followed another. My body seemed to contract around Matt’s unyielding cock as I moaned in pure animal bliss. After that, I’m not sure what happened, although at some point, I heard a strangled grunt and felt the warm flood of Matt erupting somewhere deep inside me.

For a few, perfect moments, we were frozen in a lover's knot of passion and release. Then we both collapsed and I pitched forward onto his chest. It was a good place to be, and I was content to stay there, feeling his heartbeat slow while my body moved to the rhythm of his breathing.

Matt broke the silence. “Personally, I think you look a lot more like a cute elf than old Santa Claus. But I do love your Christmas present and the way you delivered it.”

After that we were together almost every day. Since his parents both worked, it was at his home most of the time, although we did go out on dates. I’m sure everybody in town figured they knew what was going on between us. After all, everyone in our town not only knows everyone else they usually have a pretty good idea what their fellow citizens are doing. But I never heard of anyone so much as raising an eyebrow, much less objecting. That included our parents. In fact, I think they, like everyone else, approved.

Still, Matt and I knew it was just a brief affair, nothing more. He would return to the service, I’d go back to college. No strings attached. That’s how it’d always been between us. That’s how I thought it’d always be.

Then I fell in love with him. It’d been coming on for some time, but I wouldn’t admit what I was feeling. All that ended the night he beat-up Stuart, my soon-to-be ex-husband who had beaten me up, twice.

It was right after the divorce papers were filed. We were at a club with some friends. Matt still had his cast on, so we were just listened to the band while the others danced.

That’s when Stuart came over to our booth and started carrying on. Matt never moved, just told Stuart, who was trying to lean over him to get closer to me, that he should leave. When Stuart ignored him and kept yelling at me, Matt hit him several times, real fast, just how and where I’m not sure. Stuart let out this funny, gurgling noise and sank to his knees beside our table.

Matt put a hand on Stuart’s shoulder and must have done something, because I saw Stuart grimace. Then Matt pulled him a little closer, and asked, in this dead-calm voice, if he was ever going to bother me again. Stuart’s a big guy and, believe me, he’s strong. But I could see fear in his eyes as he mumbled, no.

“That’s good,” said Matt. “Cause if you do, next time will be for real.”

From then on, I was hooked. All my life, I’d felt in total control around men. It’s not my looks. I’m no great beauty, but most guys don’t seem to notice. I’d like to think it’s my eyes, and smile. Maybe those do play a part. But mostly it’s my butt and the fact I’m a total flirt.

All that ended when Stuart beat me up. After that, especially the second time, the last time, when he started for Kylie’s room before I got him to turn back on me, I would get this panicky feeling around some men. Not with Matt, of course, and after that night at the bar, not at all when we were together. Then I was my old self again, feeling safe, confidant, and in love, big time.

I’d always liked Matt, now I loved him. My problem was how to convince him he loved me.

The following week I drove him to the nearest Army post to have his leg checked. Afterward, he came out with a new cast that only covered his leg from the knee down. It was still awkward, but a huge improvement.

We stopped on the way home and made love. It was great. He could be on top without any problem. I loved it, and I loved him.

But when we got home, he told me he wasn’t just going back to the service. The Army had cleared him to go back to wherever he’d been when wounded. He felt responsible for the deaths of two friends. “I trusted someone who betrayed us. My friends are dead. He’s still there.”

I thought I was going to have a breakdown. This wasn’t fair. What scared me most was the absolute certainty he didn’t give a damn whether he lived or died, just so long as he killed that other person first.

The only thing that seemed to give him any second thoughts was my reminder that he was an only child. I begged him to think of what his death would mean to his family. But I knew he wouldn’t budge and that I might never see him again.

After Christmas, he went back to the service to spend some time at a desk job while getting his leg in shape and preparing to return to his old assignment. Meanwhile, I re-enrolled in college, waited for him to come home on leave before shipping out, and went over my very limited options. My mind kept telling me he’d be okay. But in my heart, I knew his next trip home could be the last time we’d ever be together.

That’s why I decided that, while I might never have him, maybe I could have his baby. I know it sounds crazy, but I wasn’t doing it just for me. If he didn’t come back, his parents, who I dearly love, would at least have his grandchild. Maybe that would ease their grief, make that, our grief.

So when he flew in on a two-week leave prior to going back to wherever the hell that other guy was, I met him at the airport with a big smile, and a body that was all his and free of any trace of birth control pills.

Instead of driving home, we headed for the swankiest hotel in town. The moment the door to our suite closed, Matt wrapped me in his arms and we kissed.

When our lips parted, I gave him my best, coy smile. "Do you mind me not bringing you a welcome back present?”

"Oh, but you did," he said, gently squeezing my bottom. "I was the envy of every guy in the airport."

We kissed again, but this time his hands went to work on my clothes. I’d worn a white silk blouse as a halter-top. He untied the knot holding it together. When it fell open, he cupped my breasts and I shivered with pleasure. He leaned down and took a nipple into his mouth. It was like his lips were touching my entire body.

Just when I thought I could take no more, Matt began using his tongue to trace an erotic path down toward my stomach. He knelt and teased my belly button while unzipping the very short shorts I’d picked out just for him the week before. Moments later, I felt them slid down my legs.

He watched them fall, then let his gaze travel up my body. I’d worn no underwear, thinking that might seem extra sexy. The look on his face told me it was. I stroked his short blonde hair. The gesture seemed to break his trance. Still kneeling, he tugged off my platform shoes and then pressed his head against my quivering stomach. "Damn, but I've missed you."

The emotion in the voice of this man I loved so much had me fighting back tears. I tried to pull his head even tighter against me. "And I've missed you. Oh God, how I've missed you."

The next thing I know, Matt is standing with one very startled Becky Miller cradled in his arms. "Matt, what are you doing?”

He gave me that smile I never could resist. "Can’t take a chance on you getting lost on your way to bed."

To be held in the arms of the man you love while he carries you to the bed where the two of you will make love and you may, with luck, become pregnant with his child, it was beyond erotic and so damn romantic.

After lowering me onto the bed, Matt followed me down until his fully clothed body pressed firmly against mine. A hard, fabric covered bulge pushed against me, sending jolts of sexual pleasure racing through me.

With a feeling of total contentment, I wrapped my arms around Matt, relishing the feel of his big, powerful body. We kissed for what seemed like hours. It was body-to-body, lips-to-lips, man-to-woman. Our tongues, lips, teeth, and mouths fused into a single organ of love and need.

Matt broke the kiss and, moments later, was positioned astride my middle. He didn’t say anything, just looked into my eyes as he removed his shirt.

While he tugged at his t-shirt, I began fumbling with his belt. But it was one of those strange military ones. Before I could figure it out he got off me and stood by the side of the bed. The rest of his clothes were soon in a pile on the floor.

The look on his face left no doubt what he wanted. That look, and the sight of his muscular body with its broad chest, powerful thighs and swollen cock, was way too much for me to resist. With a shudder of anticipation, I reached out for what was about to give me the passion, the pleasure, and maybe even the baby, I so desperately wanted.

Matt slid into bed and our nude bodies touched. Once again, he pressed his lips against mine while his fingers roamed over the contours of my breasts, hips, and then my thighs. When his hand slid up and took possession of my pussy, I heard myself gasp and felt my body arch up to meet his touch.

All of my senses were alive. The feel of Matt's fingers, the taste of his lips, the sight of his blatant need, the clean, masculine aroma of his flesh, even the sound of his breathing was intoxicating. After a last kiss, he began feasting on my flesh like a starving man gorging himself at a banquet.

He took his time on my breasts and throbbing nipples until I was on the verge of an orgasm. But then he stopped and began kissing his way down until he was nibbling on my oh, so sensitive inner thighs.

In one slow, smooth motion his tongue teased its way up from there until it slipped inside by pussy. It felt so damn good. Still, I wanted more. I wanted, needed, to be totally possessed by this man.

We’d been apart for what seemed like ages. No way I could wait any longer. I practically begged him, "Now Matt. I need you, now."

He looked up and studied my face, then nodded. Once again, I experienced that deliciously erotic moment when the tip of his cock touched me. Then he paused with it waiting at the opening to my churning pussy. After one more kiss, we surged towards one another and our two bodies melded into one being.

We were soon working together in a harmony of love and passion. The familiar feel of Matt's hard cock inside me was pure joy. There was no world but that room and that bed; no other time other than that incredible moment. Most of all, there was no man other than Matt, the man I loved, the man I’d missed, the man who was now taking me towards the brink of total ecstasy.

Desire, need, lust, longing, plus a totally unrestrained love pounded through every fiber of my heaving, writhing form. By then, I’d even stopped thinking about getting pregnant. I wanted nothing more than to keep making love with Matt for the rest of the day and then for the rest of my life.

The moment Matt entered me I’d begun building toward an orgasm that, when it erupted, was long, awesome, and left me tingling. Though stunned by the exquisite ecstasy, my hips kept moving in rhythm to his movements.

My climax seemed to trigger Matt’s. He began slamming into me with savage thrusts as I held him tight and savored the moment. He let out a loud groan and buried himself deep inside my hot, convulsing pussy. I luxuriated in the feel of his thick shaft throbbing as he filled me with his seed.

Afterward, we lay together, Matt still inside me, our moist bodies entwined in a lover's knot. We’d soon be making love again. But for now, he seemed sated, tired, and content. I was all of those, plus incredibly happy. Don’t ask me how, but I was certain I’d just become pregnant.

Now, eight months later, I don’t know if Matt’s alive or if he’s, if he’s not. It’s been ages since I heard from him. He warned me that might happen. Still, if he could, wouldn’t he…?

For about the millionth time since he left, I reminded myself that while I might not have Matt, at least I had his child, his son. “Matthew Hampton, Jr.,” I whispered, smiling at the sound. But then I heard myself continuing, “only child of the late Matt Hampton,” and start crying.

“This seat taken?” I didn’t look up, just shook my head and kept searching for a napkin.

Someone pulled out the chair next to me and sat down. “Is the food here that bad, or are you just sad to see me?”

Who the hell was that idiot? I turn—and I’m staring at someone who looked just like, Matt Hampton. For maybe the first time in my life, I’m speechless. Just breathing was hard enough. Before I could think of something to say, he leaned over and kissed me. It was soft and gentle, and seemed to last forever, which was still way too short for me.

Nothing made any sense. “What are you doing here?”

He smiled. “Glad to see you, too, Miss Miller.”

Then it registered. “You’re alive!” I threw my arms around his neck, bury my face against his chest, and really start bawling.

At first I didn’t want to look up. The face I saw might not be Matt’s. It could all be a dream. But then I recognized the hardness of his body, his special smell, and his gentle touch as he stroked my hair.

When I do dare to look, all I can think to say is, “Really, what happened?”

“I quit.”

“You can’t just quit—can you?”

“My mission was accomplished. My time was about up. I told the bosses I had personal business to attend to, and just sort of quit.”

“Am I that personal business?”

“Damn straight. I got a message a few weeks ago from old Dad. Don’t ask how. Anyway, he filled me in on how things have been, well, developing since I left. He said you were way too good for me, and that while there may have been a few bastards in our family, they were all self-made men, not accidents of birth.”

“He shouldn’t have done that. This was no accident,” I said, touching my belly. “I don’t want you here because you feel sorry for me.”

“I don’t, honest. I’m, I’m just…“ To my amazement, Matt looked away, but not before I saw a tear roll down his cheek. After a moment, he wiped a hand down his face. Then he turned back and gestured toward my protruding middle. “You love me that much?”

“I do.”

Once again, he looks away and then turns back. “Maybe I’ve always loved you. I don’t know—could have just been teenage lust, I suppose. But the moment you and Kylie walked into the house last year, I was hooked. And that was a problem.”

“What problem?”

Matt’s smile came back as he took my hands in his. “The problem of my going back. We went over all that and you were right about my being selfish. But it was something I had to do. The thing is, I didn’t want to leave you with a bunch of promises and, to be honest, I didn’t want thoughts of you waiting for me messing up my mind.

“Dad understood and didn’t let me know about you and the baby until after it was all over. That part took a lot longer than I’d counted on, but he was right to wait. Because since then, you and the baby and Kylie and just life itself, that’s all I can think about. So I had to get out. I want life now, not more death, and it’s because of you, because I love you. God, how I love you. Becky, will you please marry me?”

For the second time in my life I was speechless. All I could do was grin and nod. Then we’re hugging and I’m crying all the while grinning like a kid on Christmas. We kissed, and it made the first one seem like a chaste peck on the cheek. When we came up for air, I patted my very big belly. “I’m afraid it won’t be much of a honeymoon.”

“That’s all right. I’m counting on having a long life to make up for lost time. When’s the baby due?”

“Well, if your son will wait that long, around Christmas.”

“A boy, around Christmas.” He seemed pleased with the idea. “And we’re not even Jewish.”

“You’re an idiot. But I do love you.”

“And I love you, too. Always will. Remember last Christmas, when we first made love and I said I liked your presents and the way you delivered them? Well, I still do.” He pauses as his big hands gently caress my belly. “It’s just that I never counted on such a special Christmas present this year.”

Naturally, I started crying even harder and pressed his hands tighter against me. The baby picked that moment to kick. Matt laughed, then stood and helped me out of my chair. “I believe we’ve just gotten a not too subtle hint from our son to get moving on this marrying business. Where’s the nearest jewelry store? We need to buy some rings.”

“Wait. My mother will be back soon. We need to wait for her.”

“No problem. I called last night to say I was coming in, but you were giving Kylie a bath. Your mother answered the phone and told me to take a cab from the airport to the mall and meet you in the food court. She said we might want some time alone to talk things over and that she’d show up later.”

As always, my mother had been right. And for once, I was very, very glad.
 
Hope nobody minds me contributing to this - I usually read but keep quiet. :eek:

After a quicky read through as dinner cooks, the first thing I noticed was the extremely long sentence in the opening paragraph. It tripped me up and IMO could do with being broken down a little.

Thanks to her, I was, about halfway between Macy’s and totally broke, sitting alone in the mall’s noisy food-court while she finished shopping and getting her nails done, eating a tasteless salad, and wondering how I let her con me into getting dressed and driving into town to shop with her the day after Thanksgiving, the busiest shopping day of the year.

Just to illustrate, i'v had a go here - i think it reads better, but you might disagree.

Thanks to her, I was about halfway between Macy’s and totally broke, sitting alone in the mall’s noisy food-court while she finished shopping and getting her nails done. I sat there, eating a tasteless salad and wondering how I let her con me into getting dressed and driving into town to shop, on the day after Thanksgiving. It had to be the busiest shopping day of the year.

In speedy summary of the rest, I really enjoyed the story - it was sweet, especially the ending. I am guessing that there is a word count limit for the submission, but you could easily have extended parts of it?. Maybe fleshed out the encounters with the nasty ex husband?

Will have another read later. :)
 
Hi, Rumple, glad to be reading something of yours.

I like what you're doing with the voice, but I also think you forced it a bit at places. It's that, rather than an excess of back-story, that clogs the opening—in my opinion. I have a few suggestions, for whatever they might be worth, but do keep in mind they're just opinions and don't come backed up with any special kind of authority, let alone wisdom.

The first sentence (in my opinion) would read better if it were just "My mother is always right." The segue, this early on, has a weakening effect.

The remainder of the opening para struck me as problematic as well, with the next two sentences likely superfluous, and the third one difficult to read, particularly the "about halfway between Macy’s and totally broke" insertion that made me stumble.

Upon reading through to the end, I noticed something else about that part, too: it seems you introduced an unnecessary additional point in time. Matt's return happens on the same day Becky's mom dragged Becky shopping, right? If so, why should Becky tell the story from a perspective of one week later? To me it seems simpler and more logical that she tell it from the perspective of 'now', without that week between 'now' of the scene and 'now' of the narration.

Also, the rounding of the thought as to why Becky's mother is always right struck me as forced and not immediately understandable. I got the impression that Becky is pissed and miserable, sitting in that mall, and what's so right about that? The rightness, I guess, is in Becky's managing to grudgingly finish her Christmas list, but the connection between the thoughts screeched a little and made me pay more attention than it should have.

The repetitions about mother's rightness were a bit excessive and stuck in my mind so much I kept thinking of her and the role she might play throughout the story, which I'm also guessing wasn't your intention.

So my suggestion would be a thorough rewrite of the first two para's, making them as clean and to the point as possible, and the good news is that after that everything flows with only minor distractions, if that.

By that, by the way, I don't mean that you're not onto the right idea. I'd keep the "My mother is always right" opening and the general thread you're following, and I did think it gave you a very cute closing. I'd just prefer to see the thought handled in a cleaner, more straightforward way in the first two para's.

As for the rest of the small nits, they could be just a matter of taste, so in case other critics don't point them out, you'd probably do best to disregard them.

One of them is, I experienced a bit of confusion when you introduced the husband's name first, and Matt's name only after that. It certainly wasn't that difficult to figure out who was who, but still, the moment could have passed without that little pause.

Perhaps you could have mentioned Matt's name immediately, as in "The baby's daddy, Matt, left the country etc." Perhaps a simple "instead" at the end of the following sentence could have helped, too: "At the end of that semester I sort of quit, sort of flunked out of school and married Stuart Litton instead." Nothing more than little touches like that, to make it easier on the reader.

Maybe because of that momentary case of crossed wires in my mind as to which man was which, I found this confusing, too: "Like an idiot, I ignored them. Later that summer, Matt joined the service." In close succession, these two thoughts connected in my mind as if it was the husband who joined the service.

On the nittiest level of nits, I noticed a few additional places in the story where Becky's voice struck me as affected and a couple erotic formulations that lacked freshness, for my taste, but these were so small and subjective I'll only go hunt for them if others express a similar concern.

Overall, you've done a nice and clean job, which displays clearly your firm grasp of the craft. I hope I wasn't too obnoxious in focusing on the weaknesses only.

Best of luck,

Verdad

P. S. To Rachlou: Welcome! :)
 
Just a quick note to say I'm gonna chime in, but haven't had time to finish the story. I did get confused about the timing of the pregnancy, marriage and the men in the opening, but maybe I didn't read it carefully. I'll reread and see...
 
Overall, I thought it was good story, and well written.

As I read it, I kept wondering when the story was going to start, and I was a bit dissapointed that there really wasn't much of a story after all of the backstory.

I'm no expert, but I think I would go back and try to show us more of the backstory, and tell us less of it.

It was almost like I sat down beside her in the food court and she told me everything that had happened to her since whenever...and me just sitting there nodding...
 
Funny, these threads about too much narrative coming up just as I'm reading “The Scarlet Letter” for (I'm embarrassed to admit) the first time. Not only are the first forty pages of the story all narrative, but they pertain only tangentially to the central story, as the opening chapter merely sets up how the narrator happened to learn Hester Pryn's story in his capacity as an employee at the customs house.

Obviously, that's a novel, not a short story, and of course it's a different era of literature. But it caused me one of those little moments where I question the advice I encounter repeatedly re: maxims of writing and story-telling. I'm inclined to say that a relatively long bit of narrative to start off a story is fine, so long as it's sufficiently engaging.

With “A Special Christmas Present,” I don't think you need to totally re-write to trim the introductory narrative away, or even way down. But it could do with being tightened up.

The familiar, casual, conversational tone of your narrator is engaging and endearing at times, but a tad too free-style and long-winded at others. Looking at your opening two paragraphs:

My mother is always right, trust me. Not sometimes or most of the time, but always. Take last week, for instance. Thanks to her, I was, about halfway between Macy’s and totally broke, sitting alone in the mall’s noisy food-court while she finished shopping and getting her nails done, eating a tasteless salad, and wondering how I let her con me into getting dressed and driving into town to shop with her the day after Thanksgiving, the busiest shopping day of the year.

She was right, of course. Like I said, my mother is always right. To prove the point, I’d somehow managed to finish off my Christmas list. That’s good, since I’m going to be a little busy about then.


In that brief bit of text, right there in the prime real estate of your opening, you take four entire sentences to tell us, over and over, that the narrator's mother is always right. I think you can introduce that theme and the pretext for her presence there, which is the set-up for the ending and the book-end of “Mom's always right” more concisely, with a bit more punch.

As Verdad and others have mentioned, there's a lot that's confusing in that opening paragraph: the phrase “about halfway between Macy's and totally broke” threw me and required me to stop to work it out, and the next moment I'm trying to figure out who is eating that tasteless salad, because it follows on what the mother is doing while Becky waits.

Then we have this transition from paragraph three to paragraph four:

Being eight months pregnant can do that to a girl.

Make that an unmarried, pregnant girl.


You've just told us she's eight months pregnant, and in the next sentence, you give us a sentence that feels like you're giving us brand new information, but half of it's just repeating that she's pregnant.

Like others, I got a bit tangled in the web of men and pregnancies. I also thought the reference to Matt having been hurt “doing whatever it is he does,” and only later revealing he's in the military was unnecessarily confusing. I think a straightforward mention that he was injured overseas while on a tour of duty, or whatever's accurate, would be better, even if Becky doesn't know much about what his specific role is in the service.

I think if you comb through and trim away all these little repetitions, and clarify the muddy bits, the narrative will be shorter, tighter, and more compelling.

I agree with drksideofthemoon that the narrative would be a lot more engaging, too, if it were more show and less tell. Make us feel the hell that is fighting one's way upstream against a throng of holiday shoppers, the weight of her purchases pulling on her arms, the strings of her packages digging into her fingers, let us smell the mingling scents of greasy chinese food, pizza, hotdogs on sticks, etc., of the food court, that weird echoey din of hundreds of voices in the vast open mall space, the sickly fluorescents, etc. Make us feel how swollen and achey and crappy Becky feels.

And then do that with the core of the story, too. I never feel Becky's fear or rage or resentment or physical pain after her husband beats her, or her terror for her daughter's safety.

Similarly, the jump from her “limping” to her mother's with a black eye, to planning a Christmas seduction of Matt two days later doesn't make emotional sense to me, as presented. All that's needed, I think, is for you to make me feel the incredible, compelling contrast between feeling unsafe, harried, etc., that Becky's been feeling for the last however many months with Stuart, and whatever it is Becky feels when she's with Matt. What you give us:

In other words, he was a man—and I wanted him. It’d been a long time since I’d experienced that delicious flutter I now felt in my stomach. Way too long.

just isn't enough to make be ride along with Becky's playful seduction as she deals with ending an abusive marriage while looking after her little girl. Make me feel her need to be held, or to feel alive in her body, or whatever is driving her to need Matt when taking a lover is really a dangerous proposition at this point.

Once you flesh out the emotions and the sensual details, positive and negative, I think you're in good shape. I like the dynamics between Becky and Matt—his easy manner comes across nicely in their interactions, and their banter and sexual play has a genuine feel to it—teasing and not unrealistically porny. The scene where he coaxes her to try being on top for the first time is very sexy in a sweet way.

One point on characterization: I found it really troubling that Becky deliberately, secretly got herself pregnant, and her rationlizing that it was okay because a grandchild would mean a lot to Matt's parents if he was killed in action just didn't fly, because if he lives and doesn't want a kid, or doesn't want a life-long entanglement with her, she's totally fucked the guy over, even if she's prepared to let him off the hook on paternity. I'd find her actions more forgivable (though still troubling) if there was a moment in the story where Matt expressed a deep desire to be a father. It could be in passing while playing with Becky's little girl that first day they get reacquainted.

Well, hopefully there's something useful in there among my ramblings. :)

-Varian
 
I just wanted to give a quick THANK YOU to everyone for all the help. I'll wait and see if there are any more posts before making any individual comments and thank you's. The feedback has been first-rate and is much appreciated.

Rumple Foreskin :cool:
 
Others have made some good comments. As for me, I thought your story was written with a nice light touch that I enjoyed.

Maybe it's a taste difference in what gets to me, but I didn't feel the heat during the sex scenes. For example, maybe some, nibbles, and sucks, and bites interspersed within the following dialog: "Quality means a lot more that quantity. Believe me, yours are first-rate. In fact, while these prime samples of female flesh may not be the biggest, they are, without doubt, still the finest pair I've ever had the pleasure of enjoying."

Also, you used the phrase "The next day" to begin two paragraphs that were pretty close together, which stood out. And it made me notice the paragraph starting with "The following week..." Quibbles, but it seemed a bit awkward.

Oh, and I didn't mind the narrative opening. Good luck at Phaze, Rumple.
 
Hi Rumpie!

The plot reminds me a lot of 'Suzanne by the Sea': A young, pregnant woman with a missing lover recounts the history of their relationship just before he shows up out of the blue.

Those opening few paragraphs- I was there. Unfortunately, I wanted to know what would happen next much more than I wanted to know what had happened, so for pretty much the whole story I was anxious to get back to the mall. Picturing her sitting there, penniless, pregnant, and sans husband, really took away any thrill I might otherwise have gotten from the explicit scenes.

I love the voice you've given Becky. For the length of the story, she's a character with some depth- but that doesn't make her a sympathetic heroine. She's deceitful, not too bright, and maybe not quite healthy in a mental way either. This could be moving if she's changed by the story- but I don't think she is. She also might be a little more endearing in a different setting too, like Germany near the end of the Second World War? Of course, that would be all but make it another story, but her fear that her lover would not return from the war and her desperation to have his child would all make so much sense in that situation.

While we're on the subject of sympathetic, vengeance-seeking Matt wasn't exactly tugging at my heartstrings either.

I had a hard time believing Matt showing up like he does, even though it's explained a little later. It's a double let down because all Becky does is sit in the mall feeling sorry for herself for the entire story. To me, this last part is a real weakness. For this tale to be truly satisfying, I think she needs to do something. Unfortunately, I can't think of much that she can do except maybe try to call Matt and tell him the truth.

If you're working with a word-count limit, you might consider eliminating Becky's previous marriage and first child. While they do add a little depth to her character, she's deep enough and the story still works with only Becky and Matt involved. If you're not working with a word-count, it might be better to just tell the story chronologically.

I'm impressed that you're able to create a vivid character like Becky in such an economical fashion, but for the story to really work for me, I think she'd really need to grow- and unfortunately the word count would probably grow with her.

Clever the way you tied the last paragraph back to the first.

Take Care,
Penny
 
Penelope Street said:
Hi Rumpie!

The plot reminds me a lot of 'Suzanne by the Sea': A young, pregnant woman with a missing lover recounts the history of their relationship just before he shows up out of the blue.

Take Care,
Penny

I almost said the same thing, but I didn't want to seem to be tooting by own horn.
 
Last edited:
rachlou said:
Hope nobody minds me contributing to this - I usually read but keep quiet
And why would anyone mind? If there's anything to mind, it's you keeping quite the other times! :D


rachlou said:
After a quicky read through as dinner cooks, the first thing I noticed was the extremely long sentence in the opening paragraph. It tripped me up and IMO could do with being broken down a little.
I agree, that one's a bit clumsy. I got a little lost with the eating of the salad, but I really liked halfway between Macy’s and totally broke.


rachlou said:
I am guessing that there is a word count limit for the submission, but you could easily have extended parts of it?
I got the same impression. And did you think it would have been better if extended? I sure did.


Verdad said:
...particularly the "about halfway between Macy’s and totally broke" insertion that made me stumble.
LOL. Go figure!


Varian said:
I'm inclined to say that a relatively long bit of narrative to start off a story is fine, so long as it's sufficiently engaging.
Maybe any narrative is fine, so long as it's sufficiently engaging?


Varian said:
I'd find her actions more forgivable (though still troubling) if there was a moment in the story where Matt expressed a deep desire to be a father. It could be in passing while playing with Becky's little girl that first day they get reacquainted.
Great idea!


Darkside said:
It was almost like I sat down beside her in the food court and she told me everything that had happened to her since whenever...and me just sitting there nodding...
Interesting observation. Did this make the Becky's relating of her detailed sexual history feel a pinch unnatural?


Jomar said:
Good luck at Phaze, Rumple.
Agreed!

I'm curious what the requirements are for inclusion in this anthology.
 
Penelope Street said:
Originally Posted by Darkside
It was almost like I sat down beside her in the food court and she told me everything that had happened to her since whenever...and me just sitting there nodding...

Interesting observation. Did this make the Becky's relating of her detailed sexual history feel a pinch unnatural?

Not so much unnatural, more like uncomfortable. Like when some tells you more than you really wanted to know.
 
I haven't read the other comments, so please excuse me if I'm repeating someone else. And this is all nitpicky.
Overall I thoroughly enjoyed the story, but the first par jarred me seriously.
My mother is always right, trust me. Not sometimes or most of the time, but always. Take last week, for instance. Thanks to her, I was, about halfway between Macy’s and totally broke, sitting alone in the mall’s noisy food-court while she finished shopping and getting her nails done, eating a tasteless salad, and wondering how I let her con me into getting dressed and driving into town to shop with her the day after Thanksgiving, the busiest shopping day of the year.

It read like her mother was eating a tasteless salad while getting her nails done. It's a very long sentence and could easily be split in two, easing the narrative confusion.
Also she doesn't sound like Mother is right - she's tired, miserable and waiting on mum. What's right about that? Maybe you could have her saying mum is always right, even when I think she isn't. Take last week...
And why is she telling us what happened last week? Why not just let it be today? She's sitting eating her god awful lunch, tired out of her mind and thinking about the father of her child...

Didn't particularly like Matt's triumphant arrival at exactly the right moment either. Or maybe it was that she didn't immediately recognise the voice - he was so obviously in her thoughts. I found it hard to accept that she wouldn't think it was him; perhaps berate her foolish heart for thinking that, then realise it really IS him. But she'd definitely have the heart flip at the sound of his voice.
The first husband is intrusive and, I thought, not totally necessary. Her thoughts are on Matt, so any mention of Stuart should be momentary, to give credence to the safety she feels with Matt - his protection of her from Stuart - and emphasis the difference between them (I did like the "running dumb-ass" line!).

Thinking further, as I write this, I wonder about Matt. Did she hear from him at all after he left? If he cut her dead, wouldn't she be disappointed? If he didn't, he'd have to know she wasnt' going to college and wouldn't he wonder at why?
They were obviously pretty wrapped up in each other before he left. And yet she hasn't heard from him in "ages". Wouldn't she know EXACTLY how long?
I think you need to clarify the reason for the break. That she knew when he went back that she wouldn't be able to contact him or that contact would be extremely intermittent at best. He didn't want thoughts of her intruding in his work, so he'd have to have been firm on that point, even if he did have contact with his folks. Yet, he was seriously in love with her, so he wouldn't want to risk her finding someone else...

Now I'm just rambling on. I'll shut up now.
 
Penelope Street said:
I'm curious what the requirements are for inclusion in this anthology.
You got curiosity; I got guidelines.

==

THEMED HEATSHEET SUBMISSIONS

Since the launch of our first themed HeatSheet, Phaze Sparkler, we have enjoyed great success with readers and critics. It is our goal to continue publishing themed HeatSheets, 4-5 times a year, each under a different imprint. Our themed HeatSheets are a great way for new authors to join the Phaze family, and it is our goal to eventually collect the best of our HeatSheets for printed anthologies.

Frost - Deadline September 1, 2007; To be published November, 2007
Frost stories may cover any holiday (Christmas, Hanukkah, Kwanzaa) or celebrate the eroticism of the winter months. Bundle up with your favorite hero or heroine and keep the fires stoked.

Heat Sheets: 5,000 - 12,000 words (short stories)

What We Look For

Strong, passionate, intelligent characters

Intense sensual tension and situations

Well-defined, well-executed romantic plot that illustrates the mutual relationship between two to four central characters (the romantic unit) and which includes plenty of opportunity for erotic exploration and variety.

Conflict to create the tension and move the plot

Expressive language that is explicit, yet appropriate to the story

==

Rumple Foreskin :cool:
 
Penelope Street said:
I got the same impression. And did you think it would have been better if extended? I sure did.
Yes, I would have liked to read some of the back story about the relationship with her ex. The brief reference she makes in this scene =
All that ended when Stuart beat me up. After that, especially the second time, the last time, when he started for Kylie’s room before I got him to turn back on me, I would get this panicky feeling around some men. Not with Matt, of course, and after that night at the bar, not at all when we were together.
could have worked as a flashback in more detail. I don't know why but this part of the story grabbed me more so than the relationship with Matt. I wanted to know what he intended when he headed for Kylie's room - what might have happened? This snippet intrigued me. I think it could have been interesting to use this a powerful contrast to her happiness with Matt, or more so than you already have done.

I liked Beckys narrative voice - you gave me a picture of a young, rather silly girl who was fairly likeable, if a little manipulative. With reference to the pregnancy, perhaps it could have happened accidently as opposed to her planning it? We would have had more sympathy if that was the case. As Varian said (?), it was slightly troubling that she deceitfully fell pregnant without discussing it with him first.

I really liked the way you tied up the beginning and end with 'mother knows best'. It worked wonderfully.

That's it for now folks... :)
 
Last edited:
People are having trouble with the "deceitful" pregnancy, though she rationalizes it well. It might help if Matt says something about his parents asking him when he'll settle down and give them grandkids to play with (maybe when he's playing with Kylie at some point).
 
First of all, my sincere thanks to everyone who took the time to read and comment on my pitiful prose. The feedback was very helpful and resulted in a lot of editing, more dialogue, and a fair-sized reworking of the opening. Here are just a few examples.

For starters, just about everyone seemed to have a problem, or problems, with the opening. So all of you take a bow.
Here's the original opening paragraph:

My mother is always right, trust me. Not sometimes or most of the time, but always. Take last week, for instance. Thanks to her, I was, about halfway between Macy’s and totally broke, sitting alone in the mall’s noisy food-court while she finished shopping and getting her nails done, eating a tasteless salad, and wondering how I let her con me into getting dressed and driving into town to shop with her the day after Thanksgiving, the busiest shopping day of the year.

While I might have accomplished little more than re-arranging deck chairs on the Titanic, here's the revised version.

My mother is always right. Not sometimes or most of the time, but always right. Trust me. Take what happened last week at the mall.

I’m usually the slow shopper. But that day I’d finished while she hadn’t. It didn’t seem to faze her. She checked the time and said, “Just wait for me in the food court, honey. I’ll only be a few more minutes.”

So there I was, halfway between Macy’s and totally broke, sitting in that tacky excuse for a food court, eating a tasteless salad while piped-in Christmas carols competed with the noise of wall-to-wall shoppers. And I kept asking myself how I ever let my mother con me into getting dressed and driving into town to shop with her the day after Thanksgiving, the busiest shopping day of the year.


==

Rachlou: Yes, I would have liked to read some of the back story about the relationship with her ex.
I've added information about Stuart and her marriage to him. It might have done more, but I didn't want to risk shifting the focus away from the growing relationship between Matt and Becky.

But we never dated, even after that. Don’t ask me why. Maybe both of us wanted the other to make the first move. Anyway, at the end of that semester I sort of quit, sort of flunked out of school. I didn’t care. By then I was engaged to a good looking, party animal named Stuart Litton.[/B]

A few days before the wedding, Matt warned me about him. “Look, take it from me, Stuart likes to flash his family’s money and put on a good show, but he’s a sneaky-mean creep and a running dumb-ass.”

“Matt, you sound just like my mother.”

“What’d she say?”

“That being a self-centered jerk is Stuart’s best feature.”

“She’s got a point. I’ll add that to my list.”

Like an idiot I ignored them both and married Stuart. Later that summer, Matt joined the service.

Both he and my mother were right, of course. Being married was a lot of fun, at first. But the fun and games became fewer and fewer. After Kylie was born he started drinking and things went from bad, to worse, to dangerous. Last year, when he gave me a black eye as an early Christmas present, I headed for home and safety.

--

All that ended when Stuart beat me up. After that, especially the second time, the last time, when all the noise woke Kylie and she started crying and he headed toward her room yelling that he'd shut her up before I got him to turn back on me, well, after that, I would get this panicky feeling around some men.


==

Jomar: People are having trouble with the "deceitful" pregnancy, though she rationalizes it well. It might help if Matt says something about his parents asking him when he'll settle down and give them grandkids to play with (maybe when he's playing with Kylie at some point).
--
Varian: I'd find her actions more forgivable (though still troubling) if there was a moment in the story where Matt expressed a deep desire to be a father. It could be in passing while playing with Becky's little girl that first day they get reacquainted.
IMHO, those are good points and first-rate suggestions. Here's what I did.

Both of them were having fun. I’d never thought of Matt enjoying playing with a baby. “You like babies?”

“Babies is a goodness,” he said, while circling his fingers down toward my giggling daughter’s tummy. “I wouldn't mind having a few pee-pots of my own, someday.”

--

It never crossed my mind that he wouldn’t want the baby, not after watching him play with Kylie. I wasn’t so sure how he’d feel about me, though. Maybe it’d blow our relationship. That was a risk I was willing to take.


==

Rumple Foreskin :cool:
 
I think you should start the story with your revised opening, but start with the paragraph: "So there I was, halfway between Macy's..." That's a very catchy opening, and, for me anyway, it makes the first two paragraphs that precede it superfluous.
 
revision said:
Both of them were having fun. I’d never thought of Matt enjoying playing with a baby. “You like babies?”

“Babies is a goodness,” he said, while circling his fingers down toward my giggling daughter’s tummy. “I wouldn't mind having a few pee-pots of my own, someday.”

--

It never crossed my mind that he wouldn’t want the baby, not after watching him play with Kylie. I wasn’t so sure how he’d feel about me, though. Maybe it’d blow our relationship. That was a risk I was willing to take.
That's much better.


Matt said:
“My mission was accomplished. My time was about up. I told the bosses I had personal business to attend to, and just sort of quit.”
I gave the story another read while trying to keep the submission guidelines in mind. With a title like 'A Special Christmas Present', this is supposed to be an uplifting Christmas story, right? I agree, the return of a loved one would be the ultimate gift. However, happy Christmas stories also have themes like 'Peace on Earth and goodwill toward men' and I think this makes Matt's apparently successful vendetta seem a little out of place. If instead he abandons his homicidal goals, especially if he does so because of Becky's adamant opposition, then I think the story would have a more traditional holiday theme, and maybe a better chance of being accepted.

On a lesser note, Matt's military service doesn't have a realistic feel to me. Exactly what army is Matt in that he can just tell his superiors he has something to do and then leave when his time is about up? Are members of the armed forces out of touch with loved ones for months on end like Matt seems to be?


story said:
But when we got home, he told me he wasn’t just going back to the service. The Army had cleared him to go back to wherever he’d been when wounded. He felt responsible for the deaths of two friends. “I trusted someone who betrayed us. My friends are dead. He’s still there.”

I thought I was going to have a breakdown. This wasn’t fair. What scared me most was the absolute certainty he didn’t give a damn whether he lived or died, just so long as he killed that other person first.

The only thing that seemed to give him any second thoughts was my reminder that he was an only child. I begged him to think of what his death would mean to his family. But I knew he wouldn’t budge and that I might never see him again.
I want to hear this conversation. I want to hear her nervous breakdown, especially if Becky feels betrayed by Matt's 'unfair' decision- and let's him know about it in no uncertain terms.
 
Last edited:
Penelope Street said:
On a lesser note, Matt's military service doesn't have a realistic feel to me. Exactly what army is Matt in that he can just tell his superiors he has something to do and then leave when his time is about up? Are members of the armed forces are out of touch with loved ones for months on end like Matt seems to be?
I'm prepared to accept the out of touch thing, assuming Matt was in the special forces (whatever the US equivalent to the SAS is). I know SAS disappear for months on end and no one ever knows precisely where they've been.
But He'd have to have already served papers to leave the forces before he could leave, just as an ordinary soldier. I'd expect special forces to be at least as rigorous, possibly more so. Especially if he's just come off a mission.

Maybe he could be on the rundown to getting out of the forces when he returns to the mission? He's already served his de-enlistment papers, but seeks special permission to return to "finish the job" as his last assignment?

That would make Becky's position of feeling betrayed a lot more realistic. Just cos he was wounded wouldn't immediately get him out of the Forces.

(Well, it wouldn't in the Australian forces anyway - have relatives in and recently out, I'm assuming the US is similar)
 
Rumple, I've got to say, I got a quarter of the way into this, and I was gone. Lost. Glazed. I'm sorry, but you totally lost me. Your narrator is all over the place, is flat, uninteresting, and disconcertingly grim. I wish there were a better way to say it or more of a spark of hope there, but unless you find a way to grab and engage your readers with something more interesting than flabby ankles and a tastless salad from the start, she doesn't have the wit or the interest to pull this one off like this.

Sorry. I have nothing but the deepest respect for you as a writer and know you're capabable of much finer stuff. This one needs to be ripped up and redone from the start. This one's just grim.

--Zoot
 
starrkers said:
I'm prepared to accept the out of touch thing, assuming Matt was in the special forces (whatever the US equivalent to the SAS is). I know SAS disappear for months on end and no one ever knows precisely where they've been.
Ok, that could work, but I think it's worth explaining, which it pretty easy since Becky should ask about staying in touch when he's wherever he is.

starrkers said:
But He'd have to have already served papers to leave the forces before he could leave, just as an ordinary soldier. I'd expect special forces to be at least as rigorous, possibly more so.
Exactly! He should know months in advance when his enlistment would be up, and there's no reason to expect his family wouldn't know too. It makes his surprise appearance even more difficult for me to accept.
 
Zoot,

My thanks as always for your honest opinion. No question I'm much more comfortable in third person than first so to try first person with a female narrator was a stretch for me. Perhaps the changes made after some of the earlier feedback will make the piece palatable to someone, some where.

Starrkers and Penelope,

I thought about going into more detail about Matt's military background. But the story is her version of their relationship and I wanted to keep the focus there. One of those command decisions a writer has to make.

As for the discharge, for the life of me I couldn't figure out how to get into the mechanics of his leaving the service w/o screwing up the last scene--but I'm open to suggestions. Here's the skinny: Matt's hitch in the service is about up. He has decided not to re-enlist and has come home using up accrued leave time prior to his official discharge from the service.

Once again, my thanks to everyone who took the time to read my pitiful prose and then give suggestions on how the pity factor might be reduced. And I apologize for not participating more here over the last few days. A house full of kids (3) and grandkids (2) is my excuse (a nine-year old is currently hovering around, eyeing the computer like a starving vulure anxious to get at some particularly aromatic carrion). They'll all be gone after this weekend. Once I recuperate, I'll try to catch up PRN.

Rumple Foreskin :cool:
 
OK, maybe Becky doesn't know when he's due out. She knows he enlisted for X years, but isn't totally sure when he joined up (he wasn't on her radar then, she was married) and doesn't know about the accrued leave owing.
They never really discussed it in detail, because they weren't ever meant to keep this thing going after his sick leave expired.
Add to that her conviction that he's dead and it could grant you the fuzzy enough timing to get your happy homecoming scene.
 
Last edited:
Spending good times with family is not an excuse, it's a blessing. Hope you enjoyed their company.
 
Back
Top