Palestrina

Byron In Exile

Frederick Fucking Chopin
Joined
May 3, 2002
Posts
66,591
Everything he wrote was perfect.

Every note...

He defined the form.

It takes about two hundred years to understand this.
 
Jedi_Princess said:
Well, I know those two but I haven't heard of Palestrina, was he any good?
Missae Papae Marcelli?

The mass that might have saved Western polyphonic music from extinction?

Well, he was pretty good, for sure.

If he hadn't been born, we might all be chanting Gregorian chants still.
 
Byron In Exile said:
Missae Papae Marcelli?

The mass that might have saved Western polyphonic music from extinction?

Well, he was pretty good, for sure.

If he hadn't been born, we might all be chanting Gregorian chants still.


*shrug* doesn't ring a bell sorry, I may have heard it without knowing whot was though
 
Byron In Exile said:
Everything he wrote was perfect.

Every note...

He defined the form.

It takes about two hundred years to understand this.

You're older than you look.
 
Jedi_Princess said:
*shrug* doesn't ring a bell sorry, I may have heard it without knowing whot was though
Thank him for every note you hear.

Without Palestrina and Bach music as we know it would not exist.

BTW, on behalf of the dead: "you're welcome..."
 
Byron In Exile said:
Thank him for every note you hear.

Without Palestrina and Bach music as we know it would not exist.

BTW, on behalf of the dead: "you're welcome..."

Coooooool
 
Byron In Exile said:
Sir, I was old at eighteen.

How many lives can one live and not feel old?

I'm pretty sure this is my first time around. My inner child pretty much runs the place.
 
breakwall said:
I'm pretty sure this is my first time around. My inner child pretty much runs the place.
Probably.

In one way I envy you; in another way I don't.

Ten thousand lives later, what is new?

Good luck, friend; come to California, we'll put you up; I can still show you a few things.

This is my last time, but I still have a few tricks up my sleeve.
 
I think a greater debt is owed to J.J. Fux for codifying Palestrina's counterpoint in the "Gradus ad Parnassum".

And I think it's more fun to say "thank Fux for modern music".
 
phrodeau said:
I think a greater debt is owed to J.J. Fux for codifying Palestrina's counterpoint in the "Gradus ad Parnassum".

And I think it's more fun to say "thank Fux for modern music".
That is absurd.

Palestrina's music had far more influence than to wait for some dork to analyze it.

Hello.
 
Byron In Exile said:
Thank him for every note you hear.

Without Palestrina and Bach music as we know it would not exist.

BTW, on behalf of the dead: "you're welcome..."
The Dead? You're saying Palestrina influenced Jerry Garcia?
Imagine the plainchant version of "Truckin'."
 
atmas said:
The Dead? You're saying Palestrina influenced Jerry Garcia?
Imagine the plainchant version of "Truckin'."
He totally influenced The Dead, all the way, especially Terrapin Station.
 
phrodeau said:
I think a greater debt is owed to J.J. Fux for codifying Palestrina's counterpoint...
He came along after the master was dead and tried to define a system; not to subtract from Fux's work.

To Hell with codification of Palestrina. Many have tried with Bach's work with less success.

I think Jeppesen's work with Palestrina is the best.
He understands 16th Century counterpoint, and what led up to it.

You have to know Machaut, Dufay, Ockheghem, Obrecht, Des Prez, Machaut, until you get to Lassus and Palestrina. That's a whole nother fucking century or two later.
 
Giovanni Pierluigi da Palestrina is actually one of my favourite composers, his compositions of Catholic church music are amazing; and of course when it comes to Western polyphonic music he was of course most influential.

But then, I have a fondness for the music of the Church, even that of Protestant churches (especially the work of Henry Purcell).

Edited to say: Spiritus Sanctus replevit, motet for 8 voices (a bit obscure) is actually one of my favourite musical pieces ever.
 
Last edited:
I wish there were some way I could say what it is, but I can't. The human voice is the most perfect instrument there is. It is the only one made by nature, the most expressive.
 
Well, there's the old argument between creating and marketing. Who would be listening to Mahler today if it wasn't for Bernstein? Bach's popularity owes much to Mendelssohn, Mozart and Schumann.
 
Equinoxe said:
Giovanni Pierluigi da Palestrina is actually one of my favourite composers, his compositions of Catholic church music are amazing; and of course when it comes to Western polyphonic music he was of course most influential.

But then, I have a fondness for the music of the Church, even that of Protestant churches (especially the work of Henry Purcell).
His music has become perfect. All counterpoint is now compared to his. Not without merit, but still, why should all music be compared with perfection?

Shall there not be some imperfect music?
 
Back
Top