"Eenie, meenie, miney … more?" (closed)

"Did you cum?" she asked before addressing his request to try something different. She'd expected him to orgasm, what with it being his first time. But she'd forgotten that just minutes earlier, their sister's mouth had been filled with the discharge of his first orgasm with another person. Before he could answer -- she knew by his expression -- she kissed him passionately again, then pushed off of him as she said simply, "Okay."

His withdrawal caused Alice to grimace, then laugh. She teased, "You're gonna hurt a lot of girls with that thing."

Alice knew just how to get him off, and she knew just what it was going to do to her as well; it was one of her favorite positions, and she wanted to try it with Matt. Of course, he was bigger than the last couple of guys who'd come at her this way, so she was actually a bit worried.

She moved a pillow to the middle of the bed, its length running with the bed's length rather than perpendicular to it as she or Matt were laying their head on it for bed time. She folded it in half, then laid the other pillow over it without folding it in half. Slumping over the stack with the pillows under her waist, her ass was elevated in nearly a doggy style position, without her having to actually be on her knees.

"Put it in me," Alice said over her shoulder. But as Matt began to press his knees between her own, to open her up, she kept them together, telling him, "No. Your knees go outside. It'll make me tighter on you."

When Alice moved off of his lap and his cock slipped from inside of her he glanced down at his manhood that was glistening in the light from how wet it was. His entire length covered in a warm slick layer of his sister’s juices.

Once Alice got in position Matt moved behind her and after a little coaching from Alice he adjusted his legs to be outside of hers. Matt grabbed his cock and ran his tip along her wet slit. It took him a couple tries to find her hole but once he did he started sliding deep inside of her. A deep groan escaping his mouth as he pushed deep into her.

https://images.sex.com/images/pinporn/2017/12/10/460/18774327.gif

Her ass pressed up against him when he eventually buried his entire length into Alice’s pussy. “You feel so fucking good!” Matt groaned. He gripped her hips and started to slowly move his hips. He watched as his cock disappeared inside of Alice over and over again. He soon found a nice rhythm with his movements and the air started filling with the sound of their bodies clapping together.

The feel of her Matt repeatedly sinking deep inside her was very quickly driving Alice crazy with pleasure. Her groans became soft cries; her cries got louder; and as she reached up to grasp the headboard tightly in both hands and bury her face into the bedding, Alice screamed out in ecstasy.

Unlike her first orgasm upon her brother's impressive cock, this climax lasted a good deal longer … or, maybe, Alice came rapid fire a three or four times, she couldn't be certain. The explosion of pleasure was simply overwhelming and she was lost to it entirely.

She wasn't thinking it now, but she would certainly contemplate it later: after this, how was Alice ever going to be happy with another man?

The deep, in-and-out thrusting at her back side finally ceased, not that Alice had immediately realized it; her body and mind both were lost in the euphoria, and she could have very well just laid there like that and passed out. But the fuck did end, and after she realized that she had been tipped off the piled pillows and was spooning with her brother -- his cock still inside her -- she understood that Matt must have cum.

Alice wanted to say something; she wanted to compliment him. But she was in a heavenly place she'd never known before, and the knowledge that her own little brother had delivered her here was … well … mind boggling.

Instead of possibly ruining it with words, Alice instead only reached a hand back to gently urged Matt out from inside her pussy, then rolled over to face him. She pulled him in close, pressing one side of her face into his chest while she wrapped an arm around his torso.

She wanted to just lay here in her brother's arm, enjoying the afterglow of their never before experienced love making...

After a few minutes in this position with the intense pleasure Matt couldn’t hold back anymore. He wanted this moment to go on forever it felt so good. Matt wasn’t sure if he should have pulled out or not to cum and before he could decide his cock made up bus mind for him shooting his load into Alice’s pussy. It felt so much better then any previous time he had cum before this.

The siblings ended up spooning with his long throbbing cock still buried inside of her. When she eased him out his huge creamy loaf started oozing out of her pussy. When she turned to face him Matt wrapped his arms around her and held her close. After a few minutes of silent snuggling Matt brought Alice’s face off of his chest and looked her in the eyes. “Thank you Alice. That was amazing.” He said before putting his lips on hers and embracing her in a passionate sibling make out session.

Alice eagerly returned Matt's kiss, snuggling up tighter to his form; his cock has lessened in in rigidity yet was still so obvious against her belly. She wanted it inside her again, pummeling her pussy, driving her to another incredible orgasm or two or ten. But even minutes after Matt driving her to such heights, Alice's heart still hadn't quite returned to normal, and -- honestly -- she didn't know whether she could handle any more of what he had to offer.

"Matt, you are an incredible lover," she told him softly. "You have a nice cock … you're lucky in having-- in being so well endowed. But size isn't everything. Like they say, it's not enough to have a big hammer … you have to know how to use it."

She kissed him again before continuing, "Even your first time … you did very well, and I already know that with some more practice, you will make any girl … any woman you make love to very happy."

A tingle ran up Alice's spine as she finished speaking and kissed him again. She initially thought it was only because the room had cooled a bit as the sun fell down behind the tropical forest to the west of the bungalow. Then Alice realized that speaking of him getting more practice made her want to be the one giving the lessons.

Suddenly, the door of the bedroom flew open. Maggie began to speak, but as her gaze fell upon her elder sister and her younger brother embracing one another naked, the words stuck in her throat.

"What are you--?" Alice began with a tone of mixed shock, annoyance, and confusion.

But Maggie interrupted her with a tone of panic. "They're here!"

Alice opened her mouth to ask who was here … then immediately understood.

"Mom and dad!" Maggie warned as Alice leaped from the bed with the dexterity of an Olympic gymnast. "They're here! In the parking lot, coming this way!"

Alice already had her tee and thong in her hands and was heading for the bedroom door. She paused in the portal, looked for her parents -- just in case Maggie's timing had been a bit off -- then sprinted for the bedroom the three girls shared.

Behind her, Maggie's gaze was set on Matt as he reacted in his own way. From the other side of the house, Alice's loud voice called, "Maggie!"

"Sorry! Coming!" she said, taking one last look at her brother before exiting and closing the door behind her. In the living room, she smiled and blushed, contemplating the taboo activities in which the four siblings had been involved. As her sister hollered for her attention and she finally hurried that way, Maggie giggled again. "Coming, sis."

A couple of minutes later, Carrie entered the bungalow and searched the interior for anything incriminating. A moment later, her parents entered behind her, with her father bitching about how she'd just dropped the bags she was carrying in the doorway.

"Sorry, papa," she said with a lack of sincerity as she searched for but found none of her siblings. "Let me see if I can find the others. They might not even be--"

But about that time Maggie shot out of the shared bedroom, wearing an embarrassed expression and a blush. She hurried up to Carrie, whispering, "Alice is showering."

"Where's Matt?" Carrie asked, getting only a shrug from the teen who giggled. Carrie said softly, "Never mind. Help them get their bags to the bedroom … give the other two some time to--"

"Got it," Maggie said, understanding. She hurried to her folks for hugs and kisses, and as she dragged them and their bags toward their bedroom, she asked, "How was the jump over to the scuba island?"

Carrie watched the three disappear toward the bedroom, talking about their time away from their children. She waited until they were all in the room with Maggie shutting the door behind them before she rushed to Matt's room and just flew inside without knocking. "Matt!"

Laying with Alice in bed, making out as they enjoyed the post orgasmic bliss was perfect. When she started complimenting him and his manhood he grinned and was about to say that he wanted to practice more with Alice. Then their worryfree snuggling and making out came to an abrupt end when Maggie barged into the room warning them that their parents were home. “They weren’t supposed to be back until tomorrow!” Matt said as he climbed out of bed to find his clothes.

The two sisters left the room, he noticed Maggie staring at his naked body before she left. Matt grabbed a pair of shorts and a T-shirt to pull on and paused to look at the bed seeing a small puddle of cum that oozed from Alice’s pussy when they were making out. Then he got dressed and as he was pulling his shirt on he heard his door fly open. Once the shirt was pulled down past his head he laid eyes on Carrie. “What’s up?”

"You have to act-- we all have to act normal," Carrie said with an obvious tone of panic as she approached her brother. "None of this happened, none of this took place. The reason the three of us girls have gotten away with what we've been--"

She stopped just short of Matt, scrutinizing him up and down. "Oh my god, you reek of sex."

Carrie grasped his shirt and practically ripped it off of him before she turned him for and pushed him toward the bathroom. She ordered, "Go shower! Put on something different-- Oh my God! There's a fucking wet spot--"

She didn't finish as she stared at the mussed bedding while continuing to force her brother toward the bathroom. "Clean up! We'll tell mom and dad you just got back from bodyboarding and were covered in sea water. Hurry!"

She slammed the bathroom door between them and hurried to strip the bed. She stopped to look at the dark, wet spot atop the bedding for a moment and found herself imagining it had been her here with her thighs parted and her brother's big cock deep inside her pussy.

Had he enjoyed himself? Oh, surely! Had Alice? Carrie was pretty sure the answer to that was yes as well. Matt was -- had been -- a virgin, and likely he'd offered Alice little craft when it came to fucking. So, maybe she didn't enjoy it, as in cumming. (Suddenly, Carrie wished she'd listened in through the door, rather than putting some distance between them by going out to the patio while her siblings fucked.)

The realization that Matt likely hadn't had what Alice needed to orgasm made Carrie a little less disappointed about not having been with her brother. Oh, if only she'd known the truth.

She finished stripping the bed, only to find that her sibling's fluids had gone all the way through to the mattress. Fuck! Carrie was thankful that the bed was only a Queen size as she pulled the mattress back and flipped it over. Arranging it back in place, she hurried for the door and peeked out for her parents; nothing. She probably should have made the bed, too, but she needed to know what was going on out beyond the fuck palace.



An hour later, the entire family was seating around the glass table out on the patio with a lavish meal the parents had ordered and had on its way to the bungalow even before they got here. The couple was going on and on about their snorkeling and diving, about swimming with the sharks and using their laminated, underwater identification cards to investigate the coral reefs and animals living amongst them.

"How come you couldn't just enjoy the view?" Alice asked. When her parents said they didn't understand, she continued, "Just 'cause your teachers, that doesn't mean you have to make everything a learning experience. I mean, most people would just swim around looking at all the pretty coral and fish and stuff and be happy. You...! You had to take out study cards and--"

"We are teachers," her father responded, using Alice's own words. "Life is about learning. Everyone should learn something new every day. I did … your mother did--"

He glanced off toward his only son, who had always been a dedicated student, finishing, "I bet Matt learned something new today--"

In a flash, Maggie laughed quick and sharp. As eyes turned her way, she blushed a fiery red, chuckled again, then said with a knowing expression, "I'm sure he did."

She continued to giggle to herself, her hands rising to cover her mouth before she couldn't take it any longer and got up. She went inside to the kitchen to retrieve another cola, just to appear as though she hadn't been fleeing the family.

When their parents looked around to the twins for some kind of explanation, Alice felt obligated to say something -- anything -- and lied, "I think Matt went-- Didn't you take a class or something this morning...? Down at the rental place...?"

"We don't really know what Matt did today," Carrie hopped in. "He was gone all morning, and we were just hanging out here."

In the kitchen, Maggie erupted in laughter again and found it necessary to disappear back into the girls' bedroom...

Matt’s, post sex high, was short lived. Carrie started ordering him around and forcing him into the shower. Once out he got redressed in a different pair of clothes not wanting Carrie to yell at him again. Then he joined everyone out in the dining room for dinner. Matt kept flashing glances over at Alice while they ate.

Then the spotlight was put on him when his father said he bet Matt learned something new and Alice lied about him going to a class. He sipped his drink and then cleared his throat before speaking. The only thing I learned today was that I’m terrible at surfing. I took surfing lessons down on the beach today, but no matter how many attempts I tried I just couldn’t get the hang of it. I think it’s because I have terrible balance.”

It was Alice's turn to chuckle and blush, recalling how her brother had so skillfully maintained his position -- his balance -- as he lay upon her earlier, thrusting his big cock into her from behind. She caught eyes on herself this time, then apologized, "Sorry. I wasn't laughing at Matt. I'm sure … I'm sure he'll get better at it."

"Anyway..." Carrie cut in, fearful that the banter was going to begin having sexual overtones her parents couldn't help but notice. She stood and demanded of Alice, "Come help me in the kitchen with that other platter of fruit."

When Alice hesitated, her twin practically lifted her out of the chair as she told her folks, "Tell Matt more about … about whatever."

The two disappeared into the kitchen, and once they were out of hearing range, Carrie chastised Alice about her and their sister's behavior. "We kept our secret secret for years … and the very day that you involve our brother--"

"Me...?" Alice cut in a bit too loudly. She lowered her voice, then whispered, "If I recall, our brother's cock found its first joy inside your mouth, so..."

They chatted and chastised for a couple of minutes while keeping watch on the trio out on the patio. They'd kept their own incestuous affair quiet for so long; they couldn't let that all fall apart now, just because they'd added Matt to the fun.

Just about the time the twins were calm and clear enough to return to the patio, Maggie emerged from the shared bedroom wearing a skimpy bikini that her parents had forbidden her from wearing anywhere that it might cause men's cocks to harden … which was anywhere she might wear it … and certainly, after what had happened today, was right out there on the patio.

"What are you doing?" Alice growled at her youngest sister. "Take that off."

Maggie shrugged and reached for the string at the back of her neck, saying, "Okay."

Both twins grasped their sister and turned her back for the bedroom. Once beyond the door, Carrie chastised, "What's wrong with you?"

"I want to lose my virginity," she answered bluntly. When the other two simply stared at Maggie, she clarified, "I want to lose my virginity … today."

Alice and Carrie stared dumbfounded at their younger sister, then looked to one another. Maggie had been part of the discussions about leading their brother into manhood, but neither had thought she wanted to be part of actually doing it because she herself had never been with anyone but the twins.

After a moment, Alice shrugged to Carrie, then looked to Maggie and said, "I'm sure that Matt would be more than happy … thrilled actually … to be your first."

The other two sisters left the table shortly after Maggie did. After Carrie mentioned they should tell Matt more about their excursion, their parents continued to tell him about their experiences on the island. Matt acted like he was listening but all he could think about was the sex he just had with Alice. They moved to the living room to put a movie on, but shortly after the parents retired to their room.

After a long day that involved snorkeling, hanging out on the beach, then losing his virginity, Matt was going to go to bed to get some rest. He was in his room picking something on the tv to fall asleep watching when Maggie entered his room. She stood there in an oversized T-shirt that was very thin and he could see a tiny red bikini under that shirt. “Hey Maggie. What’s up?” He asked sitting up and leaning against the headboard.

“Hey Maggie. What’s up?”

The youngest of the three sisters leaned back against his bedroom door, staring at her brother with a sense of panic, her heart pounding so hard she could feel it in her ears. She hadn't planned on this -- on coming to Matt's bedroom for sex -- when she's been telling her sister what she wanted to have happen this night...



Earlier in the evening:

"I want to lose my virginity," Maggie said. "I want to lose my virginity … today."

Alice and Carrie were caught off guard, but -- presuming she knew what her younger sister had meant -- Alice responded, "I'm sure that Matt would be more than happy … thrilled actually … to be your first."

"I don't mean Matt," Maggie clarified.

Again, Alice made a presumption: "Did you meet someone here on the island … a guy … who interests you?"

"I didn't meet him here on the island," Maggie said. She hesitated a moment, amazed that she was about to say this. "I met him 19 years ago … in the hospital with mom."

It took a moment for the twins to understand, and almost simultaneous their faces filled with shock. Carrie was the first to react with, "Are you crazy...? You want … you want dad to take your virginity?"

"Why not?" Maggie asked innocently.

"Because he's your father!" Carrie growled just barely above a whisper.

But Maggie only countered, "Sure, and Matt is my brother but you don't have a problem with that."

"This is different," Alice finally chimed in.

"Why? Because you haven't fucked him first?" Maggie said with an almost accusatory tone. She turned her eyes to Carrie, adding, "Or sucked his cock? Why can't I be the first one to be with him?"

"It's not about--"

"That's not it!"

The two twins moved closer to their sister as they talked over one another, trying to get their own objections across to their sister.

"Stop!" Maggie snapped, finally bringing them both to silence. She drew and released a deep breath before continuing more calmly, "It isn't about that … sorry … I didn't mean to imply that that was the reason."

"Then what's the reason?" one of the twins asked.

Maggie continued, "I trust dad."

A moment of silence passed, with neither of the twins knowing quite what to say.

"I know I can trust Matt … I don't mean that either," Maggie finally said. "I can trust him to keep this all a secret, just as the two of you have for years with each other … just as you have kept us a secret for all these months. That's not what I mean."

Alice stepped closer and took her younger sister's hands into her own, asking, "Sweetie, just tell us what's on your mind."

Maggie contemplated a long moment, then said, "Matt doesn't know what he's doing. I mean, he only just learned-- He only just lost his virginity this afternoon--"

She looked in to Alice's eyes, her own threatening to tear up and wet her cheeks before she continued, "--and I know that you had fun and that he did good and all … but Alice, c'm'on, that was mostly you … you were the one leading Matt."

What her sister was saying was true in a sense, but still, Matt had done mighty well for it being his first time. Mighty well; Alice hadn't in years had such an explosive orgasm, a series of orgasms, placed to closely together that they'd practically been one never ending climax.

But, as Alice had told her brother, Matt was a natural at fucking, and it wasn't just because he had a big cock. She told Maggie, "I think that if you gave Matt a chance, you'd see that--"

"I don't want to take a chance," the youngest sister cut in. "I want it to be magical for me, just as it was magical for Matt."

Alice took Maggie into her arms for a long, silent hug, then -- when a thought struck her -- she separated them and said with a smile, "I have an idea."

And now Maggie was standing before Matt in his room. Their parents were already passed out in their own bedroom, victims of three long days of never ending and exhausting fun; they would be dead to the world until long after sunrise tomorrow.

"I need you to come with me, Matt," Maggie said, moving over to his bed and reaching out a hand. "C'm'on."

She led him out of his room and across to the girls' room, closing the door behind them. It seemed almost a replay of yesterday morning when Matt had come to the bungalow's biggest room and learned they were going to find him a lover by day's end, only this time Carrie was standing in the bathroom door looking hesitant and Maggie was the one leading Matt over to the bed to take a seat.

"Maggie wants to lose her virginity to you tonight, Matt," Alice began explaining from where she was leaning against the bureau, Carrie's position from the morning before. She waited for Matt's reaction, then continued, "But … Maggie's … concerned. She wants to ensure this is a memorable experience for the both of you … and … since you've never … well … one of the things … what I'm trying to say is--"

From the bathroom, Carrie interrupted with, "Maggie has only ever had one of us between her thighs … pleasuring her with our mouths and fingers--"

"Carrie!" a suddenly embarrassed Maggie snapped, blushing a fiery red.

"What, it's the truth, and you two are taking to long," Carrie defended herself. She came out from the bathroom door to near Maggie and Matt, continuing, "Your little wants us to show you how to use your mouth on her … before you fuck her--"

"Carrie!" The chastising was from Alice this time. The eldest of the three sisters moved closer as well, looking to Matt as she explained in more detail, "We thought that maybe you might want to watch the three of us together … to see what pleases Maggie … before … before you made love to her."

Maggie was still blushing as she looked into her brother's eyes and asked with a hopeful tone, "I mean … if you'd like that, Matt."

Matt followed Maggie to the girl’s room and once inside he saw Carrie standing there as well as Alice. His eyes widened when he heard that Maggie wanted to lose her virginity to him. Matt just lost his hours earlier and was now about to have sex with a second girl. Watching his three sisters together pleasuring Maggie just the thought was enough to give him a semi.

“Yes I would like that a lot!” Matt said while nodding his head.